Dense foam material: Provides long-lasting support and prevents flattening for lasting comfort
Three size options: Ensures a precise fit for different foot shapes and sizes
Self-adhesive and removable: Allows easy installation and removal without damaging shoes
Reduces extra space: Offers a tighter fit for narrow feet, improving stability
Podiatrist-inspired design: Addresses common foot slippage issues in high heels
Summarized by Shop
The Shoe Fairy's exclusive insert is here! Designed to fit perfectly in our Olympian Heels. We searched high and low for an insert to solve a common problem: feet sliding forward in high heels.
Turns out, we just could not find what we wanted! So, we created our very own. We received insight from a podiatrist and went to work!
Sold as a
Material
High quality dense foam
Sizes
Three different sizes available
Adhesive
Self-adhesive, removable
Fit
One size fits all with size options
Recommended use
Keep in shoe for optimal adhesive strength
Sold as
Pair
Summarized by Shop
4.8
141 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
MOST COMFY SHOES EVER
These are hands down the most comfortable high heels I have ever worn in my freaking life. I cannot say enough good things about them!
I was SO skeptical about ordering from The Shoe Fairy because the specific shoes I needed are considered a narrow fit, and I have wider feet. I actually held off on buying them for way too long because I was convinced they wouldn’t work for me. Now I’m mad at myself for waiting!
I followed their sizing recommendations and sized up. I’m typically a 7.5–8 in most shoes, but because of my wider feet, I ordered a size 9. They fit like an absolute glove. I maybe even have a tiny bit of wiggle room, but I would MUCH rather have a little extra room than have my feet crammed into a heel, especially when I’ll be posing and walking in them on show day.
I also ordered the ball-of-foot cushion inserts just in case I needed a little extra comfort or a more secure fit, and honestly, I don’t even think I need them. But I’m glad I have them as an option!
I genuinely cannot get over how freaking comfortable these shoes are. I was expecting competition heels to be something I’d just have to tolerate, and these completely proved me wrong. I cannot WAIT to wear them on show day.
I will absolutely be ordering from The Shoe Fairy again. The quality of these heels completely exceeded my expectations, and based on this experience, I wouldn’t hesitate to try their other products either.
10/10. If you’re hesitating like I was.. BUY THE SHOES 👠✨
B
Brooke · August 13, 2026
Shoes
A
Aikaterini · 19 days ago
Disappointing. Straps too big...previous versions fit great
This isn't my first pair in this size/style, but sadly it's the only one that has oversized straps around the foot. I contacted customer service, exchanged them, and still had the same issue. I didn't want to have to buy ankle straps after years of wearing the same shoe, but it seems it's the only way it'll stay on my foot.
