Fantastic Four Pack

Overpriced and over hyped

Overpriced and Overhyped: Wouldn't Buy Again Bought the popular Fantastic Four pack (which includes the M&M Peanut Butter, MVP, and two other flavors) after seeing all the Instagram hype, but I was deeply disappointed. I tried the MVP brownie first, and while it wasn't dry, it was completely plain and disappointing. It practically tasted sugar-free—almost like a dessert made for diabetics rather than a premium treat. It lacked any richness or real flavor, giving the vibe of a cheap, generic gas station brownie rather than a high-end specialty dessert. Given the price tag and the massive online buzz, this fell way short of expectations. Definitely overpriced, massively overhyped, and not something I'll ever buy again.

Loved these brownies i broke my budget just to try them and it was worth every penny. I was impatient in the shipping process and even sent an email complaining about how long it was taking ( my anxiety got high) i got an email from zack letting me know i neednt worry and a week later i received my brownies. Stay cool guys and look forward to my next order with yall.

I ordered 3 orders of the same selection for 3 different people. None of them had ever tried buckeye brownies. They were astounded at their size one ate the peanut butter brownie in their order and the other person in their order ate the snickerdoodle brownie. 100% thumbs up and both chose to freeze the remaining 3 for another time. As for the 3rd order that would be for me and I froze all 4 brownies to contribute as a dessert for a group trip in September.