Customizable taffy mix: Choose up to 10 flavors to create a unique blend for your taste
Freshly made in the USA: Ensures quality and freshness with every order
Gluten-free and nut-free: Safe for those with dietary restrictions
Individually wrapped pieces: Easy to serve, decorate, or share
Kosher certified: Meets dietary requirements for kosher consumers
Summarized by Shop
Discover your favorite flavors by creating your own 2-pound custom mix of taffy flavors and get them fresh from our factory! Choose up to 10 different flavors! Each flavor choice represents 10% of the total mix. So, if you would like more of one flavor than another, just continue to add that flavor to the flavor choices until you reach th
Box Weight
2 lb
Flavor Options
Up to 10 custom flavors
Allergens
Contains egg whites and milk; free from tree nuts, peanuts, and gluten
Dietary Preferences
Nut-free, gluten-free, kosher
Packaging
Individually wrapped pieces with red Taffy Town lettering
Summarized by Shop
4.8
273 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Wonderful Flavors
Have found little packages throughout stores and decided to try the website where there were alot more flavors and every single one that I had tried and added to my box was spot in for flavors. Will definitely order again.
C
Chris · August 25, 2026
custom box
every one who had a sample liked them all very much with some good ones: licorice swirl, cherry cola, banana split and caramel swirl. other than that l will order again
T
tom · August 15, 2026
Great tasting soft taffy!
Loved the flavors I picked for my box except 1. I chose Watermelon, Grape, Pineapple, Strawberry, Strawberry Kiwi and Green Apple. Green Apple was the only one that was just ok. Everything else was fantastic..