This is the product description text that will appear here.
Quantity
1
Classic and endlessly comfortable–our iconic penny style is known to be the most comfortable, exceptionally made and detailed loafer out there. Handcrafted in El Salvador.
4.5
42 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Elba Penny Loafer
The shoe is beautiful and very well made. A “heavier “ loafer than some of it’s competitors-
I have ordered another pair once the color is back in stock.
I am between an 8.5 and 9. First ordered the 9 and was too big — the 8.5 fits with room.
C
Carolyn · October 23, 2026
Best/most beautiful loafer
This is my second review of these shoes - my first pair in the brown hickory I purchased in an 8.5 and they were a touch too large (normal size) so I exchanged for an 8 - they fit well, but are taking quite some time to break in (several weeks) and cut into my ankles. Bandaids help, but it is still ongoing. This did not deter me from purchasing a second pair - the black croc. Which are incredibly gorgeous - 10/10 recommend with the crescent add on - such a statement shoe. Now when I tried them on in the size 8 - it was a totally different experience - they fit perfectly out of the box and they don’t seem to have a break in period and do not hit in the same spot on my ankles. A few notes: this pair didn’t come with the shoe horn, nor did it have the protective covering on the sole (these are non issues as they clearly weren’t worn and I have a shoe horn from the other pair - but it just seemed unusual). They certainly elevate my style and I now understand why some reviews exclaim about the comfort out of the box. I suspect that there is the variation due to materials used and I believe they are handmade…. I absolutely love the black croc and would recommend. I wish both pairs were equally and comfortable and I hope the hickory crocs ‘break in’ soon!
M
Michelle · July 17, 2025
Beautiful shoe
I’ve been looking at these for months and trying different loafers at a more affordable price point - but I finally pulled the trigger. They are so beautiful. I originally purchased 8.5 (my normal size) and they were too large. I exchanged for a size 8 which fit well. I have been trying to break in with socks that I would wear with running shoes - but they do seem to have an extended break in period. Similarly to other reviews, they dig in just under my ankles. This is solved with bandaids. I hope they break in soon (going on 3 weeks) - just ordered a second pair in black croc because the hickory croc is so beautiful!
