Single-note vanilla custard delivers a bright, clean flavor for a classic taste experience
Rich egg custard and yellow cake crumbles provide a satisfying, creamy texture
Bittersweet chocolate fudge ties the dessert together for a balanced, indulgent finish
Handcrafted in small batches for consistent quality and freshness
Available in a convenient 1 pint size for easy sharing or personal enjoyment
Summarized by Shop
Jeni has always had a soft spot for Boston Cream Pie. First for its deep roots in American history—originally made in the 1850s in Boston in an era when the words “cake” and “pie” were interchangeable. And because no other dessert combines chocolate and custard together in such a satisfying way. Our vanilla custard is truly amazing, made
Flavor
Vanilla custard with egg custard, yellow cake, and chocolate fudge
Serving Size
1 pint
Allergens
Milk, Eggs, Wheat (in some variants)
Dietary Preferences
None specified
Brand
Jeni's
Summarized by Shop
4.6
185 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Exceeded our expectations
When you read a well written description, you often don’t assume that the product will actually match. But the ice cream flavors and the descriptions mirror each other beautifully for a wonderful taste, bud experience
A
Anna · 16 days ago
Best get well gift!
My good friend (who happens to love ice cream) is recovering from surgery. We sent her 5 pints of Jenni’s. She was so surprised and so happy. She loves every flavor we sent her.
A
Annie · August 3, 2026
Boston Cream Pie
It was really good. Not as good as Brambleberry crisp but still good