Banana cream pudding is a mouthful of texture. Dense pudding made with vanilla and real bananas. Airy whipped cream. And soft wafer cookies to anchor it all.
What makes fresh banana pudding so perfect is the way these beautiful ingredients play off each other. A little bit of everything in one spoonful. That is what we've replicated in thi
4.3
223 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
For non-dairy, pretty darn solid
I admittedly didn't read the 'non-dairy' part, so my first bite was underwhelming. However- once I realized it, I swapped out the categorical expectations, and enjoyed it. Good banana flavor, not just something that tastes too artificial. The dairy replacement is primarily coconut, so factor that in. There are also plenty of wafer/pastry-type pieces. It is easily the best non-dairy ice cream I've had.
J
Josh · August 12, 2026
I always like Jeni’s Ice Cream! I purchased the banana cream pudding for our daughter! It is one of her favorite flavors! Unfortunately, I did not notice that I ordered a dairy free option. She did not like the ice cream; especially the coconut cream part.
So, I will be eating that ice cream flavor, which is ok.
Patricia · July 16, 2026
So excited to write THIS review! You guaranteed ice cream would arrive frozen and you delivered!! I lve in Oklahoma and its HOT! Local stores do not carry all flavors so i gave online ordering a shot. Treats arrived during peak heat in oklahoma and proved the test of time completely frozen and beautifully packaged!! Thank you Jenni