Four classic candy flavors in one treat for a unique taste experience
Honey-infused ice cream delivers a dreamy, nougat-like texture
Made with simple, recognizable ingredients for a clean label
Pretzel pieces add a crunchy, savory contrast to sweet flavors
Summarized by Shop
Four ingredients to rule them all: Peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels. Plus one not-so-secret ingredient — honey — which gives our peanut butter ice cream a dreamy, nougat-y texture and flavor. Think of eating this flavor like digging for buried treasure. There's something fun to be found in every single bite!
Heads up: we’re in
Allergen Information
Contains peanuts, milk, wheat
Dietary Preferences
No specific dietary restrictions
Format
Pint
Brand
Jeni's
Sub Brand
High Five Candy Bar
Summarized by Shop
4.6
313 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Like a Take 5 Candy Bar, but Better
The flavor combo is familiar and fantastic. The salty and sweet ingredients hit all the right notes that you'd get from a candy bar made with similar ingredients, but the creamy ice cream takes this treat to the next level.
A
Adam · August 19, 2026
love love love this flavor...waiting to try cherry vanilla w/chocolate covered waffle cone pieces
C
Carole · 16 days ago
Strawberry Pretzel Pie is to DIE for!
I’m a chocoholic and usually gravitate to all things chocolate,but the Strawberry Pretzel Pie was to DIE for! The Key Lime Pie is also a fave and wild love to see that on the regular rotation!!