Granny Smith apples with cinnamon: Delivers a classic, sweet and tart apple pie flavor
Cane sugar and allspice blend: Adds depth and warmth to the pie's taste
Traditional streusel topping: Provides a flaky, crunchy texture
Baked to order: Ensures freshness and peak quality
Customizable for shipping: Crumble topping replaced with lattice crust for convenience
Summarized by Shop
Granny Smith apples with cinnamon, cane sugar and a pinch of allspice, slow cooked beneath our fabulous streusel topping.
9" Diameter serves 6 to 12.
Baked to order. Please allow 24 to 48 hours advance notice required before pick up or shipping.
Note: For shipping orders, crumble topping will be replaced with a lattice crust.
Diameter
9 inches
Serves
6 to 12
Baking Time
24 to 48 hours advance notice required
Topping
Streusel (crumble) or lattice crust for shipping
Flavor Profile
Apple, cinnamon, cane sugar, allspice
Summarized by Shop
4.0
11 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Unimpressive. It tasted like a grocery store pie at best. I was truly disappointed. The pie was not on par with other desserts I've had from your bakery.
A
Anonymous · July 16, 2026
Delicious. This pie was the first to be eaten at our family Christmas celebration.
J
Jordan · January 4, 2026
Overpriced
The pie was fine. But I am wondering why it cost $4 more to pick it up from your store than if I had bought it at Natural Grocers. I paid $28 for this pie, that is more than $4.50 for each serving (cut into 6 servings).