Of all the old bar soaps, my favorite was Sea Salt. It was refreshing, clean but not overpowering. Pacific Dive is more aligned with the Sea Salt + Citrus line found in the 2-in-1 shampoo and deodorant products. Still a clean and subtle scent that I have enjoyed so far, since I could not get Sea Salt bar soap anymore. Basically, if you like a less aggressive scent for your soap, then I highly recommend it.
I won't give it 5 stars however, for 2 reasons: grit and color. First, they added in kelp for a mild bit of exfoliation. Personally, I don't typically like exfoliating soap, but this one isn't too bad. It's got enough texture for dirt and dry skin, without being so rough it severely scratches you up. I would prefer it without the kelp exfoliant, but it won't stop me from continuing to use it. Second, while I do enjoy the pleasant sea green color of the soap... I don't enjoy seeing streams of sea green water pooling in the bottom of the shower and leaking from the bar down the side of my shower after I put it back down. Is that just a side effect of the kelp, too much Chromium Oxide Green, or something else? I don't need soap that looks pretty, I just need it to clean my body. The old Sea Salt bars were a boringly calm, flat gray color and did the job perfectly well (without producing streams of vibrantly colored water).
Bring back the old bar soaps; even if they aren't the 2-in-1 soap/shampoo bars, I'd still buy them. I think the old ones last longer, too.