A time-tested favorite, our hand-rolled Garlic bagels add the zesty crunch of lightly baked garlic – changing both the taste and texture into something so many New Yorkers crave!
Of course the numerous health benefits of garlic are well known, and a Garlic Bagel from New Yorker Bagels stands well on its own, adorned with cream cheese, lox
4.8
69 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Not so good
With a name like New York Bagels you expect the bagels to be fabulous but I wasn’t impressed. They even fell apart when you tried cutting them in half. The taste was also not so good. I didn’t like the fact I was thumbing around the order site and evidently I inadvertently ordered garlic bagels. I sure hope it’s not a subscription. The garlic particles fell off on my finger.
K
Kevin · September 7, 2026
No garlic on the garlic bagel
I thought the bagels might be a little stale with two day shipping, but they were delicious. I froze them, and after thawing it was still chewy and scrumptious. My only complaint is the garlic bagels had a seasoning on top--no garlic. Next time, I'll do an everything bagel.
S
Suzanne · August 22, 2026
NY BAGELS
As always,GREAT!!!
Thank you NEWVYORK BAGELS!!
🥯❤️
