Graeter's Lemon Meringue Pie is incredibly creamy marshmallow lemon ice cream with crumbles of pie crust and bursts of tart lemon candy crunch.
4.9
27 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Blew my mind
The lemon flavor was so strong and very refreshing something I never thought I would say about ice cream being refreshing. The lemon candies gave it an even stronger lemon taste for the next bite which i loved and added texture and crunch to it which was nice. At first i wasnt getting alot of pie pieces and I was thinking despite being lemon meringue pie, it would still be good without the pieces until i got further down and got more of them and it was definitely needed. Just like the smores where if you just had graham cracker ice cream, if you just had lemon ice cream with or without the candies, I would buy it
J
Jon · 2 days ago
Perfection.
My absolute favorite flavor. It's perfection, and it isn't so chock full of inclusions that it comes off tasting like a candy bar.
B
Boston · September 26, 2026
Been wanting to try it, wish I'd bought two! Light and not too sweet, very refreshing and yummy!