ShadowThorn Beast Plush Toy

Exclusive offer available

VampireFreaks

Cthulhu Plush Toy

(18)

$19.99

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Classic Mothman Cryptid Crush Plush

(24)

Exclusive offer available

Steady Hands

Mothman Plushie

(13)

$35.00

Glitch Productions Store

4.9

(93.9K)

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Gorgon Cryptid Crush Plush

(20)

Twisted Cryptids: Loveland Frog 4" Reversible Plushie

Exclusive offer available

TeeTurtle

Twisted Cryptids: Loveland Frog 4" Reversible Plushie

(1)

$4.00$10.00

Squishable

Mini Squishable Haunted Mothman

(15)

$36.00

Exclusive offer available

TeeTurtle

Plushiverse Myths and Cryptids Reversible Plushie Mystery Box

(39)

$8.00

Perished Plushies

Hemlock Jackalope Plushie

$35.00

Exclusive offer available

FairyGlen Store

My First Cthulhu Plush

$24.99

Kazoodles Toys

Alter Ego Ghost - Slime

$22.99

Exclusive offer available

CuddlyCryptids

Mothman Stuffed Plush Toy

(25)

$31.99$35.00

Bleak Boutique

Wendigo Folk Horror Cryptid Plush Toy

(5)

$24.95

Flatwoods Monster cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

Flatwoods Monster Plushie [Pre-Order]

(4)

Haunt Homies

4.9

(564)

Plushie Dreadfuls - Glammoth Cryptid Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal toy

Exclusive offer available

Mysterious

Glammoth Cryptid Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal

(19)

Logan's Toy Chest

Nightmare Critters Plush Toy – Cute & Creepy Horror Stuffed Animal

$15.97

Wendigo cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

Wendigo Plushie

(68)

Cozy Coven

Crow Plush Toy

$13.99

Squishable Toy Stuffed Plush Squishables Ectoplasm Baby Mothman

Exclusive offer available

Off the Wagon Shop

Squishables Ectoplasm Baby Mothman

$10.99$22.99

Deluxe Creations and Designs

Kreeptures - Vampir Witchcraft Plush Toy

$40.00

Squishable 3 Inch Micro Clip Baby Mothman Plush Toy - Owl & Goose Gifts

Owl and Goose Gifts

Squishable 4 Inch Micro Clip Baby Mothman Plush Toy

(7)

$16.99

13% off

PlushThis| Plushies & Stuffed Animals

Stuffed Skeleton Ghost Mummy

(2)

$19.99$22.99

Fahlo

4.9

(90.8K)

PlushThis| Plushies & Stuffed Animals

Black Goth Crow Plush Toy

(29)

$16.99

TOTYM

(365)

'Knox' the Grim Reaper 💀 | Plush - TOTYM

The Cryptids Americana sticker pack featuring all four essential cryptids: Mothman, Flatwoods Monster, Bigfoot

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

Cryptids Americana Sticker Pack

$10.00

Haunt Homies

The Summoning

(535)

$29.99

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Gloomicorn Cryptid Crush Plush

(13)

Perished Plushies

Cryptid Fetal Friends | Mothman

$23.00

Jellykoe

"Classic Mothman" plush

(1)

$25.00

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

Artist Series: Ryan Pallett Cryptid Sticker Pack

$15.00

Plushie Dreadfuls - Loch Nessie - Plush Cryptid Stuffed Animal toy

Exclusive offer available

Mysterious

Loch Nessie - Plush Cryptid Stuffed Animal

(11)

$40.00$50.00

Perished Plushies

Cryptid Fetal Friends | Lochness Monster

$20.00

PlushThis| Plushies & Stuffed Animals

4.7

(1.6K)

Skeleton stuffed animal plush soft toy pillow pals plushie

Exclusive offer available

Pals Plushies

Skeleton

$57.49

Cryptoids Toys

Young Shadow Bigfoot

$45.00

Fresh Finds Gifts

Spook Jr.

$32.99

Exclusive offer available

VampireFreaks

Gargoyle Plush Toy

(12)

$19.99

Exclusive offer available

CuddlyCryptids

Chupacabra Stuffed Plush Toy

(2)

$24.99$34.97

Kids' card games

Matching, memory, and bluffing games.

Plushie Dreadfuls Dreadful Cryptid Rabbit Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal toy

Exclusive offer available

Mysterious

Dreadful Cryptid Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal

(22)

Twisted Cryptids: Bigfoot 4" Reversible Plushie

Exclusive offer available

TeeTurtle

Twisted Cryptids: Bigfoot 4" Reversible Plushie

(1)

$4.00$10.00

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Werewolf (Red Eyes) Cryptid Crush Plush

(4)

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Werewolf (Yellow Eyes) Cryptid Crush Plush

(17)

Squishable

Squishable Baby Mothman

(37)

$58.00

embroidered halloween skeleton wendigo stuffed animal plushie

Exclusive offer available

VampireFreaks

Wendigo Plush Toy

(6)

$19.99$31.99

Goth Oasis

Cute Skeleton Plush Toy

$35.00

The Thrifty Mountaineer

Baby Mothman Plush

$29.99

VampireFreaks

4.8

(26.1K)

A promotional graphic for a 'Mystery Plush' featuring multiple models with colorful hair holding various plush toys, set against a vibrant purple and pink background with stylized text.

Jellykoe

"Bigfoot" plush toy

$25.00

Squishable

Mega Squishable Baby Mothman

(7)

$135.00

Plushie Dreadfuls - Wraith Bun Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Exclusive offer available

Mysterious

Wraith Bun - Plush Stuffed Animal

(21)

$36.00$45.00

Exclusive offer available

CuddlyCryptids

Mythical Kelpie Plush with Poseable Bendable Tail

(4)

$35.99

Mothman, Bigfoot, Wendigo, Flatwoods Monster cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

The Whole Gang

(8)

$199.00

Plushie Dreadfuls Shy Bigfoot Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal toy

Exclusive offer available

Mysterious

Shy Bigfoot - Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal

(29)

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Pink Lemonade Mothman Cryptid Crush Plush

(12)

Tiny tea party

Tea sets, pretend treats, and trays.

Avantris Entertainment

Creepy Crow Plushie

(4)

$40.00

Kazoodles Toys

Micro Mothman

$18.99

Close up view of a stuffed Bigfoot doll, on a teal green plush sofa. The doll has reddish hair, with a light brown wrinkled face and very large brown feet.

Stands

Limited Edition Sasquatch | Plushie

(1)

$36.00

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Dragon Cryptid Crush Plush

(7)

Front view of Midnight Mothman plush with wings folded over face, featuring black celestial wing pattern and soft midnight blue body.

Rebel Romance

Mini Squishable Midnight Mothman Plush Toy

(1)

$48.00

Exclusive offer available

FairyGlen Store

Cthulhu Plush

$19.99

CloverPuff

Goth Moth

$40.00

Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Doll - Soft Stuffed Animal Birthday Halloween Gift ABCDEFGH (8pcs)

Exclusive offer available

Cozy Kawaii

Nightmare Critters Plush Toy Doll - Soft Stuffed Animal Birthday Halloween Gift

(2)

$34.99$62.99

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Grimshroud Mothman

(40)

$65.00

Exclusive offer available

CuddlyCryptids

Little Krampus Stuffed Plush Toy

(5)

$25.99$40.00

Bigfoot cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive offer available

Strange Fellows

Bigfoot Plushie [Pre-Order]

(7)

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Scarred Werewolf Cryptid Crush Plush

(26)

Twisted Cryptids: Mothman 4" Reversible Plushie

Exclusive offer available

TeeTurtle

Twisted Cryptids: Mothman 4" Reversible Plushie

(2)

$4.00$10.00

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Unicorn Cryptid Crush Plush

(6)

36% off

Monster Stuff Store

Plush Yeti

$12.00$18.75

Cryptoids Toys

Shadow Mothman - Deluxe Action Figure

$45.00

Slime sets

Starter kits, creature jars, and tools.

Exclusive offer available

Witching Hour Baby

Halloween Haunt-Ted the Ghost Plush Toy

$13.00$23.00

Sasquatch Clothing Company

8" Plush Bigfoot

(1)

$11.99

Exclusive offer available

Tiny Teeth

Jersey Devil Cryptid Crush Plush

(10)